UF filter, carbon filter or reverse osmosis: what does each one remove?

No filter can remove everything from the water whilst leaving everything you want to keep in it. Below, the three techniques are presented side by side, so you can choose whichever is most important to you.

Ultra-fine filter (UF)our standardActivated carbon filteroptionReverse osmosiswe do not sell
Asbestos fibres, microplastics and nanoplasticsYesNoYes
BacteriaYesNoYes
Chlorine, odour and tasteYes (coal seams)YesYes
PFASNot the membrane; the carbon layers may reduce it (not measured)Reduces PFAS; in a study of carbon filters for home use, 60–70 per cent of long-chain PFAS were removedMost of all: almost completely
Minerals remain in the waterYesYesNo, unless they are added again
WastewaterNoNoYes, a lot

Our standard: the ultra-fine filter

In the Netherlands and Belgium, we supply the Alpha water ioniser as standard with the ultra-fine (UF) filter. The reason for this is asbestos: some of the old water pipes are made of asbestos cement. The membrane has pores measuring 0.01 microns and traps particles such as asbestos fibres, micro- and nanoplastics, and bacteria. The filter also contains layers of activated carbon to remove chlorine, odours and tastes.

PFAS: what is and isn’t allowed

PFAS molecules are about ten times smaller than the pores of a UF membrane and are dissolved in the water. A membrane like ours therefore does not retain them. Activated carbon works differently: it binds PFAS to its surface and can therefore reduce its concentration. The extent of this reduction depends on the type of PFAS, the contact time and the age of the filter.

Researchers from Duke University and NC State University tested domestic water filters. Carbon filters removed around 60 to 70 per cent of long-chain PFAS; reverse osmosis removed almost all of them. Our own filters have not been tested for PFAS. That is why we do not quote a percentage.

The option: the activated carbon filter

If PFAS is your main concern, you can have the Alpha supplied with the activated carbon filter instead of the UF filter. Please bear in mind that the carbon filter does not trap the smallest particles, such as asbestos fibres and nanoplastics. The two filters cannot be used in the appliance at the same time. The filter lasts for around eight months; you can switch between them when replacing it.

Why we don’t sell reverse osmosis systems

Reverse osmosis extracts the maximum from the water, including PFAS. However, it also removes minerals such as calcium and magnesium, and produces a lot of waste water. Find out the difference between a water ioniser and reverse osmosis.

Not sure which filter is right for you? Take the decision-making guide or request a quote; you select the filter in the quotation.

Sources

Are you concerned about PFAS in your tap water?

The Water Guide explains in eight steps what’s going on and what you can do about it at home.

Launch the Water Guide

Calculate your payback periodCalculate your costs →Which model is right for me?Take the decision-making guide →

Would you prefer some personalised advice? +31 85 401 0083

Wondering how much it costs: at home, at work or on the move?

Take the two-minute kitchen scan and receive a personalised quote for your home or business, including installation. If you’re out and about, you can order the portable H2CapPlus directly in-store.